Understanding the Plural of “Brother”: Meanings, Usage, Rules, and Common Pitfalls in English

by

Forming plurals in English is usually a straightforward process, but certain words can present unique challenges. The word “brother” is one such example, offering not just the regular plural “brothers” but also the less common, more formal “brethren”. For English learners, teachers, writers, and editors, understanding when and how to use each plural is essential for clarity, correctness, and effective communication.

The choice between “brothers” and “brethren” is not simply a matter of memorizing forms—each carries its own grammatical, cultural, and contextual significance. Using the wrong plural can result in confusion or unintended meaning, especially in formal, religious, or literary contexts.

This comprehensive guide is designed to help you master the plurals of “brother”, exploring the rules, exceptions, examples, and common pitfalls. You’ll learn the history, structure, usage contexts, and practical applications of both “brothers” and “brethren”, supported by tables, examples, and exercises.

Whether you are a language student, educator, or advanced writer, this article will equip you with the tools to use these forms with confidence and accuracy.

Table of Contents

3. Definition Section

3.1. What Is a “Brother”?

A brother is a noun that most commonly refers to a male sibling—someone who shares one or both parents with another person. The word also extends to mean a male member of a group, such as a religious order, fraternity, or close-knit organization.

Etymology: The word “brother” comes from Old English brōþor, which has cognates in many Indo-European languages. Over centuries, it has maintained its core meaning, although its extended uses have grown.

Table 1: “Brother” in Different Languages
Language Word Pronunciation
French frère [fʁɛʁ]
Spanish hermano [eɾˈmano]
German Bruder [ˈbruːdɐ]
Italian fratello [fraˈtɛllo]
Russian брат (brat) [brat]

3.2. What Is a Plural Noun?

A plural noun refers to more than one person, animal, object, or concept. In English, pluralization is typically formed by adding -s or -es to the singular noun (cat/cats, box/boxes). However, many nouns, like “child” or “man,” have irregular plurals (children, men).

Plural nouns are essential for clear communication, allowing speakers and writers to specify number and avoid ambiguity.

3.3. Plural Forms of “Brother”

There are two plural forms of “brother” in English:

  • Brothers: Regular plural, used for biological siblings or informal groups.
  • Brethren: Irregular/archaic/collective plural, used in religious, formal, or metaphorical contexts.
Table 2: Plural Forms of “Brother” – Summary
Plural Form Typical Meaning Context/Usage
Brothers Male siblings; informal group members Family, everyday speech
Brethren Male members of a religious/fraternal group Religion, formality, literature

4. Structural Breakdown

4.1. Standard Pluralization: “Brothers”

To form the standard plural of “brother,” simply add -s at the end, following the regular English pluralization rule for most nouns.

  1. Start with the base word: brother
  2. Add -s: brother + s = brothers
Table 3: Regular Pluralization Patterns
Singular Plural Rule Applied
sister sisters add -s
father fathers add -s
brother brothers add -s

4.2. Irregular/Collective Plural: “Brethren”

The word brethren is the irregular plural of “brother,” developed from Old and Middle English forms. Historically, it was used to refer to members of a religious faith or formal group, and is still found in religious, literary, or ceremonial contexts today.

“Brethren” is considered irregular because it does not follow the standard -s pluralization rule and involves a vowel change (a process called ablaut), similar to child/children or ox/oxen.

4.3. Phonetic and Morphological Elements

Let’s compare the pronunciation and structure of “brothers” and “brethren”:

  • Brothers: /ˈbrʌð.ərz/ (two syllables)
  • Brethren: /ˈbrɛð.rən/ (two syllables; note the vowel change)
Table 4: Phonetic Transcription and Syllable Count
Word Phonetic (IPA) Syllables Morphological Change
brothers /ˈbrʌð.ərz/ 2 brother + s
brethren /ˈbrɛð.rən/ 2 vowel change, -en ending

4.4. Usage Contexts Overview

The choice between “brothers” and “brethren” depends heavily on the context. Here’s an overview:

Table 5: Contexts and Appropriate Plural Form
Context Correct Plural Form Example
Family (siblings) brothers I have two brothers.
Religious group brethren Let us pray, dear brethren.
Fraternal organization brethren (sometimes brothers) The Masonic brethren gathered for the meeting.
Metaphorical (“brothers in arms”) brothers They are brothers in arms.

5. Types or Categories

5.1. Sibling Plural (“Brothers”)

In everyday speech, “brothers” is used to refer to two or more male siblings. It appears in family conversations, stories, and most informal contexts.

  • My brothers and I share a room.
  • She has three brothers.
  • Are your brothers coming to the party?

5.2. Fraternal/Religious Plural (“Brethren”)

“Brethren” is most often found in religious texts, formal organizations, or historical contexts. It refers to members of a faith, congregation, or brotherhood.

  • Dear brethren, let us gather in worship.
  • The brethren voted on the new leader.
  • He addressed the brethren of the society.

5.3. Metaphorical or Figurative Use

Both “brothers” and “brethren” can be used metaphorically. “Brothers” is more common for close comradeship (“brothers in arms”), while “brethren” appears in formal groupings (“brethren of the craft”).

Table 6: Metaphorical Uses
Phrase Meaning Plural Used
brothers in arms close comrades, especially in the military brothers
brethren of the craft members of a professional group or guild brethren
brothers in faith fellow believers brothers/brethren

5.4. Comparative Table of Plural Types

Table 7: Plural Types Comparison
Type Plural Form Example
Sibling brothers My brothers play football.
Fraternal/Religious brethren The brethren gathered for service.
Step/Compound brothers-in-law Both my brothers-in-law attended the wedding.

6. Examples Section

6.1. Basic Examples: “Brothers”

Here are ten simple sentences using “brothers” in a family context:

  1. My brothers are older than me.
  2. She visits her brothers every weekend.
  3. We have two brothers and one sister.
  4. Are your brothers twins?
  5. His brothers live in New York.
  6. Both brothers enjoy playing chess.
  7. I gave my brothers a gift.
  8. Do your brothers speak Spanish?
  9. Our brothers help us with homework.
  10. The brothers shared a secret.

6.2. Basic Examples: “Brethren”

Here are ten sentences illustrating “brethren” in religious, historical, or formal contexts, with brief explanations:

  1. Dear brethren, let us begin the ceremony. (Addressing a religious congregation)
  2. The brethren of the lodge meet every Thursday. (Fraternal organization)
  3. Ye are all brethren in Christ. (Biblical style, spiritual kinship)
  4. The brethren voted unanimously. (Formal decision-making group)
  5. Our brethren overseas need our support. (Members of the same faith abroad)
  6. The ancient brethren passed down these traditions. (Historical context)
  7. He welcomed his brethren with open arms. (Formal, literary greeting)
  8. The brethren gathered for the annual council. (Formal assembly)
  9. Let us remember our fallen brethren. (Commemorative, often military or religious)
  10. The brethren sang hymns together. (Religious service)

6.3. Complex Sentences and Advanced Usage

Here are ten advanced sentences using plural forms, modifiers, prepositional phrases, or possessives:

  1. My two older brothers’ achievements have inspired me to work harder in school.
  2. The brethren of the ancient order, known for their wisdom, gathered under the old oak tree.
  3. All my brothers from different mothers met for the first time last summer.
  4. The council invited the brethren who had traveled from distant lands.
  5. The brothers’ shared passion for music led them to form a band together.
  6. The elders addressed the assembled brethren with solemn words of unity.
  7. Among my brothers, only one chose to become a doctor.
  8. The brethren’s dedication to charitable work is widely admired.
  9. She spoke to her brothers-in-law about the family’s new business venture.
  10. The society’s brethren, both young and old, participated in the ceremony.

6.4. Examples in Literature and Media

Table 8: Examples from Literature and Media
Source Plural Used Context/Quote
Bible (Matthew 23:8) brethren “…for one is your Master, even Christ; and all ye are brethren.”
Shakespeare, Hamlet brothers “Now cracks a noble heart. Good night, sweet prince, and flights of angels sing thee to thy rest! … And flights of angels sing thee to thy rest, And flights of angels sing thee to thy rest, And flights of angels sing thee to thy rest!” (implied, not direct, but familial context)
J.R.R. Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings brothers “Boromir and Faramir were brothers.”
Freemason Rituals brethren “Brethren, let us begin the work of the lodge.”
Military Memoir brothers “They were brothers in arms.”

6.5. Comparative Example Table

Table 9: Comparative Sentences Using Both Plural Forms
Sentence with “Brothers” Sentence with “Brethren” Meaning/Context Change
My brothers are coming to dinner. My brethren are coming to dinner. Family vs. formal/group
I miss my brothers from school. I miss my brethren from the congregation. Friends/family vs. religious group
They are brothers in arms. They are brethren in arms. Comradeship (casual) vs. formal brotherhood
The brothers shared a secret. The brethren shared a secret. Siblings vs. group members
The brothers’ house is large. The brethren’s house is large. Family home vs. organization’s building

6.6. Examples with Compound Nouns

Pluralizing compound nouns like “brother-in-law” can be tricky. The correct plural is brothers-in-law.

  1. Both my brothers-in-law attended the holiday dinner.
  2. She has three brothers-in-law living in different cities.
  3. All my brothers-in-law are very supportive.
  4. Her two brothers-in-law helped organize the event.
  5. Do you get along with your brothers-in-law?

6.7. Error Analysis Example Table

Table 10: Correct vs. Incorrect Usage
Incorrect Sentence Corrected Sentence Explanation
I have two brethren. I have two brothers. Use “brothers” for family members.
My brothers-in-laws are doctors. My brothers-in-law are doctors. Pluralize the first noun in compound forms.
The brothers voted at church. The brethren voted at church. Use “brethren” for religious group voting.
We invited all our brethren to the family reunion. We invited all our brothers to the family reunion. Family context requires “brothers.”
He addressed his brothers at the lodge meeting. He addressed his brethren at the lodge meeting. Formal group context prefers “brethren.”

7. Usage Rules

7.1. When to Use “Brothers”

  • When referring to male siblings in a family
  • In informal or casual social contexts
  • In metaphors about close friendship or solidarity, especially outside religious or formal organizations

Example: “I have two brothers living in Chicago.”

7.2. When to Use “Brethren”

  • When addressing or referring to a religious group, especially in Christianity, Judaism, or certain fraternal organizations
  • In formal or ceremonial language
  • In literary or historical contexts

Example: “The brethren gathered for evening prayer.”

7.3. When Not to Use “Brethren”

  • Do not use “brethren” for biological siblings in modern English
  • Do not use “brethren” in casual, everyday family conversations
  • Be cautious in secular or non-formal settings—”brethren” can sound archaic or pretentious

Incorrect: “My two brethren are coming over.” (Correct: “My two brothers are coming over.”)

7.4. Pluralization of Compound Nouns

For compound kinship terms like “brother-in-law,” the first noun is pluralized:

Table 11: Singular & Plural Forms of Compound Kinship Terms
Singular Plural
brother-in-law brothers-in-law
sister-in-law sisters-in-law
father-in-law fathers-in-law
mother-in-law mothers-in-law

7.5. Regional and Dialectal Variations

  • Both American and British English favor “brothers” for siblings and “brethren” for religious/formal groups.
  • Some dialects may use “brethren” more frequently in religious communities, but the distinction is generally consistent across varieties.
  • Informal contractions (e.g., “bros”) are common in colloquial speech, but not standard or formal.

7.6. Exceptions and Special Cases

  • In older English literature, “brethren” was sometimes used for siblings, but this is now obsolete.
  • Creative writers may use “brethren” metaphorically for dramatic effect, but this is stylistic, not standard.

8. Common Mistakes

8.1. Incorrect Use of “Brethren” for Family

  • Incorrect: “I have three brethren.” (for siblings)
  • Correct: “I have three brothers.”

Explanation: “Brethren” is not used for biological siblings in modern English; use “brothers” instead.

8.2. Overgeneralizing Irregular Plural

  • Incorrect: “All my brethren attended the party.” (casual, family context)
  • Correct: “All my brothers attended the party.”

Explanation: “Brethren” is reserved for formal or religious groups, not casual gatherings of siblings.

8.3. Mispluralizing “Brother-in-law”

Table 12: Incorrect vs. Correct Pluralization of Compound Nouns
Incorrect Correct Rule
brother-in-laws brothers-in-law Pluralize the first noun
brother-in-law’s brothers-in-law Do not add ‘s to the whole phrase
brethrens brethren “Brethren” is already plural

8.4. Pronunciation Errors

  • Mispronouncing “brethren” as /ˈbrʌð.rən/ (should be /ˈbrɛð.rən/)
  • Mispronouncing “brothers” as /ˈbrʌð.ɪrz/ (should be /ˈbrʌð.ərz/)

Tip: Practice aloud or use online dictionaries with audio to master correct pronunciation.

8.5. Confusion with Other Irregular Plurals

Table 13: Irregular Pluralization Patterns
Singular Plural Pattern
child children -ren ending
ox oxen -en ending
brother brethren (irregular) vowel change + -en
man men vowel change

8.6. Misuse in Written vs. Spoken English

  • Using “brethren” in casual conversation (sounds overly formal or outdated)
  • Using “brothers” in a formal church address (may lack appropriate solemnity)
  • Mixing up “brothers-in-law” and “brother-in-laws” in writing

9. Practice Exercises

9.1. Fill-in-the-Blank

  1. I have two ____ who love to play soccer.
  2. The ____ of the church gathered for prayer.
  3. All the ____ in my family are younger than me.
  4. The ____ decided to form a band.
  5. Our ____ overseas need our support.
  6. His ____ are all doctors.
  7. The ____ welcomed the new member warmly.
  8. My ____ are coming to the reunion.
  9. The ____ have a special ceremony every year.
  10. Among my ____-in-law, one is a chef.

Answer Key:

  1. brothers
  2. brethren
  3. brothers
  4. brothers
  5. brethren
  6. brothers
  7. brethren
  8. brothers
  9. brethren
  10. brothers

9.2. Error Correction

  1. My two brethren are coming home for dinner.
  2. She has three brother-in-laws.
  3. The brothers of the church will meet at 7 PM.
  4. He addressed his brothers at the lodge meeting.
  5. We invited all our brethren to the family picnic.

Answer Key and Explanations:

  1. My two brothers are coming home for dinner. (“Brethren” is incorrect for siblings.)
  2. She has three brothers-in-law. (Pluralize “brother,” not “law.”)
  3. The brethren of the church will meet at 7 PM. (“Brethren” for religious group.)
  4. He addressed his brethren at the lodge meeting. (“Brethren” for formal group.)
  5. We invited all our brothers to the family picnic. (“Brothers” for family context.)

9.3. Identification Exercise

  1. My brothers are twins.
  2. The brethren voted on the new rule.
  3. I have two brethren in my family.
  4. The brothers of the fraternity are organizing an event.
  5. The brethren gathered at the temple.
  6. All his brothers-in-law are doctors.
  7. We met our brethren from other countries.
  8. I gave my brothers a gift.
  9. The brethren’s choir sang beautifully.
  10. My brothers-in-law are visiting next week.

Key and Explanations:

  1. Correct (“brothers” for siblings)
  2. Correct (“brethren” for group)
  3. Incorrect (Should be “brothers” for family)
  4. Correct (“brothers” can be used in fraternity context, though “brethren” is more formal)
  5. Correct (“brethren” for religious group)
  6. Correct (“brothers-in-law” is correct plural)
  7. Correct (“brethren” for group from other countries)
  8. Correct (“brothers” for siblings)
  9. Correct (“brethren’s” for group possessive)
  10. Correct (“brothers-in-law” for compound plural)

9.4. Sentence Construction

  • Write a sentence using “brothers” in a family context.
  • Write a sentence using “brethren” in a religious context.
  • Write a sentence using “brothers-in-law” in a social context.

Model Answers:

  • My brothers and I went hiking last weekend.
  • The brethren gathered in the sanctuary for evening prayers.
  • All my brothers-in-law attended the wedding.

9.5. Multiple Choice

  1. Which is the correct plural for male siblings?
    • a) brethren
    • b) brothers
    • c) brotheres
    • d) brethrens
  2. In a church, you should address the group as:
    • a) brothers
    • b) brethren
    • c) brotherins
    • d) brothern
  3. The correct plural of “brother-in-law” is:
    • a) brother-in-laws
    • b) brothers-in-laws
    • c) brothers-in-law
    • d) brother-in-lawes
  4. Which word is not an irregular plural?
    • a) children
    • b) brethren
    • c) men
    • d) brothers
  5. “Brethren” is most appropriate in:
    • a) texting your siblings
    • b) formal religious service
    • c) casual conversation
    • d) talking about your friends

Answers:

  1. b
  2. b
  3. c
  4. d
  5. b

9.6. Advanced Application

Edit the following paragraphs to use the correct plural forms:

  1. My two brethren are visiting from Canada. We always have fun when all the brethren get together at the family reunion.

    Edited: My two brothers are visiting from Canada. We always have fun when all the brothers get together at the family reunion.
  2. During the annual meeting, all the brothers of the lodge voted on the new rules. The brothers agreed unanimously.

    Edited: During the annual meeting, all the brethren of the lodge voted on the new rules. The brethren agreed unanimously.
  3. She has three brother-in-laws, and her husband has two brethren working at the same company.

    Edited: She has three brothers-in-law, and her husband has two brothers working at the same company.

9.7. Practice Exercise Table

Table 14: Practice Exercise Guide
Exercise # Task Correct Answer Explanation
9.1 Fill in the blank: “The ____ of the church welcomed the new member.” brethren Religious/formal context
9.2 Error Correction: “My two brethren are coming home.” brothers Family context
9.3 Identify: “The brothers-in-law arrived late.” Correct Compound plural is correct
9.4 Write a sentence with “brethren” (religious context) The brethren sang hymns together. Appropriate use for religious group
9.5 Multiple choice: “Plural for male siblings?” brothers Standard pluralization
9.6 Edit: “She has three brother-in-laws.” brothers-in-law Correct compound plural

10. Advanced Topics

10.1. Historical Linguistics: Evolution of “Brethren”

The word “brethren” dates back to Old English (brēþer), evolving through Middle English as a double plural (first adding a vowel change, then the -en suffix). This pattern is shared with other archaic plurals like “children” and “oxen.”

Table 15: Timeline – Evolution of “Brethren”
Period Form Notes
Old English brōþor / brōþru Original forms
Middle English brether / brethren Ablaut + -en added
Modern English brethren Archaic/formal plural

10.2. Semantic Shift: Changing Meanings Over Time

Originally, “brethren” could refer to any brothers, but its meaning narrowed to religious or formal groups. In literature, this shift reflects changing social and cultural norms.

  • 16th century: “Brethren” used for siblings and group members.
  • 21st century: “Brethren” almost exclusively for formal or religious groups.

Example: Shakespeare’s usage of “brethren” often implied both literal and figurative brotherhood.

10.3. Pluralization in Religious and Cultural Contexts

“Brethren” is particularly prominent in Christian, Jewish, and some fraternal organizations. It embodies the idea of spiritual kinship.

Table 16: Verses/Passages Using “Brethren”
Text Passage Context
Bible (Romans 12:1) “I beseech you therefore, brethren…” Apostolic address
Book of Mormon “And now, my beloved brethren…” Spiritual address
Freemasonry Ritual “Brethren, let us begin.” Fraternal organization

10.4. Gender-Inclusive Language

Modern English increasingly favors gender-inclusive plurals like “siblings” or “brothers and sisters” to include all genders.

  • Siblings (neutral, all genders)
  • Brothers and sisters (explicit inclusion)

Note: “Brethren” traditionally refers to males, though some organizations use it generically.

10.5. Comparative Linguistics

Other languages have their own ways of pluralizing “brother.” Let’s compare:

Table 17: Plural Forms in Other Languages
Language Singular Plural Literal Translation
French frère frères brothers
Spanish hermano hermanos brothers (also siblings)
German Bruder Brüder brothers
Italian fratello fratelli brothers (also siblings)
Russian брат (brat) братья (brat’ya) brothers

11. FAQ Section

  1. What is the correct plural of “brother” in everyday English?

    In everyday English, the correct plural is brothers.
  2. When should I use “brethren” instead of “brothers”?

    Use brethren in religious, formal, or ceremonial contexts, or when referring to members of a faith or formal organization.
  3. Is “brethren” still used in modern English?

    Yes, but mainly in religious, historical, or ceremonial language. It’s rare in everyday speech.
  4. What is the plural of “brother-in-law”?

    The correct plural is brothers-in-law.
  5. Can “brethren” be used in non-religious contexts?

    Rarely. It may appear in formal or literary contexts, but generally not in casual or family conversation.
  6. Are there other English words with similar irregular plurals?

    Yes: children, oxen, men, women, geese, mice, etc.
  7. How is “brethren” pronounced?

    /ˈbrɛð.rən/ (BRETH-ren)
  8. Why does English have two plural forms for “brother”?

    Due to historical linguistic development: “brothers” follows regular pluralization, while “brethren” is an archaic, collective form used for groups.
  9. How do I know which plural form to use in writing?

    Consider the context: use “brothers” for family/siblings, “brethren” for religious/formal groups.
  10. What are some common errors with the plural of “brother”?

    Using “brethren” for family, mispluralizing “brother-in-law,” or using “brothers” in formal religious addresses.
  11. Are there differences in usage between British and American English?

    No major differences; both use “brothers” for siblings and “brethren” for formal/religious groups.
  12. Can “brethren” refer to women or is it male-only?

    Traditionally, “brethren” refers to men, but some organizations use it generically. For inclusivity, use “siblings” or “brothers and sisters.”

12. Conclusion

Mastering the distinction between “brothers” and “brethren” is key for anyone aiming for clarity and accuracy in English. Remember, “brothers” is the standard plural for family and informal groups, while “brethren” is reserved for religious, ceremonial, or formal contexts.

By understanding the rules, contexts, and exceptions, and by practicing with examples and exercises, you can confidently choose the correct plural form every time. This knowledge not only improves your grammar but also enriches your cultural and communicative competence in English.

Continue practicing, consult this guide as needed, and enjoy the richness that comes from mastering even the trickiest corners of English grammar!

Leave a Comment