Mastering the Past Tense of ‘There is/There are’: Forms, Rules & Usage

by

One of the most fundamental yet sometimes confusing areas of English grammar involves existential sentences—those that tell us something exists or is present. In everyday conversation, we constantly use expressions like “There is a book on the table” or “There are many students in the classroom” to provide information about the presence, quantity, or existence of people and things.

For Spanish speakers, this structure relates closely to the word “hay”, which means both “there is” and “there are.” Naturally, learners often wonder: How do I express the past tense of hay in English? The answer lies in mastering “there was” and “there were”, which are essential for talking accurately about people, objects, or situations that existed in the past.

Whether you’re telling stories, describing past events, or giving background information, using these forms correctly is vital. This comprehensive guide is designed for English learners at all levels, Spanish speakers transitioning to English, ESL/EFL teachers, and grammar enthusiasts who want an in-depth understanding of past tense existential sentences.

In the following sections, you will find clear explanations, numerous examples, tables, practice exercises, guidance on common mistakes, and advanced usage notes. By the end, you will confidently use existential sentences in the past tense to communicate clearly and accurately.

Table of Contents

  1. Definition Section
  2. Structural Breakdown
  3. Types or Categories
  4. Examples Section
  5. Usage Rules
  6. Common Mistakes
  7. Practice Exercises
  8. Advanced Topics
  9. FAQ Section
  10. Conclusion

3. DEFINITION SECTION

3.1. What is ‘Hay’ and its English Equivalent

In Spanish, the word hay functions as an existential phrase meaning both “there is” (singular) and “there are” (plural). It indicates the presence or existence of something without specifying a particular subject.

In English, we distinguish singular and plural explicitly:

  • There is — singular, e.g., “There is a book.”
  • There are — plural, e.g., “There are three cars.”

This article focuses on expressing the past tense equivalents of these phrases: “there was” and “there were.”

3.2. Grammatical Classification

Sentences starting with “there” used this way are called existential sentences. They state that something exists, is present, or is available.

In these, “there” is known as a dummy subject or existential subject because it doesn’t refer to a specific person or thing but introduces the idea of existence.

The main verb is “be”, which changes form based on tense and number:

  • Present: is / are
  • Past: was / were

3.3. Function and Usage Contexts

Existential sentences in the past tense are used to:

  • Express existence or presence in the past: “There was a concert last night.”
  • Describe availability or unavailability: “There weren’t any tickets left.”
  • Set the scene in narratives: “There were many people at the park.”
  • Provide background information: “There was a problem with the engine.”

3.4. Importance of Correct Usage

Using these forms correctly is essential for:

  • Clear communication: Precise past descriptions avoid confusion.
  • Grammatical accuracy: Correct agreement prevents common errors.
  • Transferring from Spanish: Avoiding mistakes like using “there is” for past events.
  • Building complex sentences: Forming negatives, questions, and clauses accurately.

4. STRUCTURAL BREAKDOWN

4.1. Basic Past Tense Forms

In the past tense, English distinguishes singular and plural as follows:

Tense Singular Plural
Present there is there are
Past there was there were

4.2. Affirmative Structures

The basic pattern for affirmative existential sentences in the past:

There + was/were + noun phrase (+ time expression)

Examples:

  • “There was a problem.”
  • “There were several mistakes.”
  • “There was a concert last night.”

4.3. Negative Structures

To form negatives, add not after was or were:

There + was/were + not + noun phrase

Commonly, contractions are used:

  • was not → wasn’t
  • were not → weren’t

Examples:

  • “There wasn’t any milk.”
  • “There weren’t any calls.”
Full Form Contracted Form
There was not a problem. There wasn’t a problem.
There were not many people. There weren’t many people.
There was not any noise. There wasn’t any noise.
There were not any tickets. There weren’t any tickets.

4.4. Question Forms

Form questions by inverting was/were and there:

Was/Were + there + noun phrase + ?

Examples:

  • “Was there a meeting yesterday?”
  • “Were there any issues?”
  • “Was there enough food at the party?”
  • “Were there many accidents last winter?”

4.5. Short Answers

To respond briefly:

  • Yes, there was.
  • No, there wasn’t.
  • Yes, there were.
  • No, there weren’t.

4.6. Time Expressions Commonly Used

Common past time markers include:

  • Yesterday
  • Last week/month/year
  • Two days ago
  • In 1990
  • When I arrived
  • At that moment

Placement examples:

  • “There was a storm last night.”
  • “Two weeks ago, there were many tourists.”
  • “There weren’t many options in the past.”
  • “Were there any problems yesterday?”

5. TYPES OR CATEGORIES

5.1. Singular vs. Plural Existentials

The choice between was and were depends on the noun:

  • Use there was + singular noun: “There was a mistake.”
  • Use there were + plural noun: “There were mistakes.”

Some nouns, like news or information, are uncountable singular and take was.

5.2. Countable vs. Uncountable Nouns

Uncountable nouns (water, sand, information) use there was:

  • “There was water on the floor.”
  • “There wasn’t any money.”

Countable plural nouns use there were:

  • “There were cars parked outside.”
  • “There weren’t many chairs.”

5.3. Indefinite Quantifiers

Words like some, any, many, a lot of, few, several influence meaning but not verb agreement:

  • “There were many reasons.”
  • “There weren’t any calls.”
  • “There were several problems.”
  • “There wasn’t much noise.”

5.4. Emphasizing Quantity or Absence

Use quantifiers to add nuance:

  • “There were only two tickets left.”
  • “There was just a small mistake.”
  • “There were hardly any people.”
  • “There were a few complaints.”
  • “There was plenty of food.”

6. EXAMPLES SECTION

6.1. Basic Singular Examples

  • There was a storm last night.
  • There wasn’t a problem.
  • There was an accident on the highway.
  • There was a letter for you.
  • There wasn’t any coffee left.

6.2. Basic Plural Examples

  • There were three emails.
  • There weren’t any cookies left.
  • There were several mistakes in the report.
  • There were many tourists at the museum.
  • There weren’t enough chairs.

6.3. Countable/Uncountable Examples

  • There was sand on the beach.
  • There were cars parked outside.
  • There wasn’t much money in the wallet.
  • There were apples in the basket.
  • There was snow on the mountain.

6.4. Questions Examples

  • Was there a test yesterday?
  • Were there enough chairs?
  • Was there any news?
  • Were there any complaints?
  • Was there a reason for the delay?

6.5. Negative Sentences Examples

  • There wasn’t any milk.
  • There weren’t many people.
  • There wasn’t much traffic this morning.
  • There weren’t any problems with the system.
  • There wasn’t any noise from the construction site.

6.6. Complex Sentences Examples

  • There was a time when I loved swimming.
  • There were several occasions when he visited.
  • There wasn’t any food left when we arrived.
  • There were many reasons why they canceled the trip.
  • There was a moment when everything changed.

6.7. Examples with Time Expressions

  • There was a concert two weeks ago.
  • Were there any complaints last month?
  • There wasn’t much rain in 2010.
  • There were many accidents last winter.
  • There was a big celebration on New Year’s Eve.

6.8. Examples with Indefinite Quantifiers

  • There were some issues with the system.
  • There wasn’t much noise.
  • There were a few empty seats.
  • There weren’t any calls this morning.
  • There were many reasons for concern.

6.9. Tables of Examples

Affirmative Negative
There was a problem. There wasn’t a problem.
There were many people. There weren’t many people.
There was some noise. There wasn’t any noise.
There were several reasons. There weren’t several reasons.
Question Affirmative Answer Negative Answer
Was there a meeting? Yes, there was. No, there wasn’t.
Were there any issues? Yes, there were. No, there weren’t.
Was there enough food? Yes, there was. No, there wasn’t.
Were there many accidents? Yes, there were. No, there weren’t.
Countable Uncountable
There were books everywhere. There was water on the floor.
There were apples in the basket. There wasn’t any sugar left.
There weren’t enough chairs. There wasn’t much money.
Were there any tickets? Was there any noise?
Time Expression Example Sentence
Yesterday There wasn’t any news yesterday.
Last week There were several meetings last week.
In 1990 There was a famous concert in 1990.
Two days ago There were problems two days ago.
Quantifier Example Sentence
Many There were many questions.
Some There were some complaints.
Any There weren’t any messages.
Much There wasn’t much traffic.
A few There were a few errors.

7. USAGE RULES

7.1. Agreement in Number

Make sure verb agreement matches the noun:

  • Singular noun + was: “There was a cat.”
  • Plural noun + were: “There were cats.”

Be careful with collective nouns or nouns that look plural but are singular (e.g., news).

7.2. Choosing Between ‘Was’ and ‘Were’

With quantifiers:

  • Some, many, several + plural noun + were: “There were many problems.”
  • Much + uncountable noun + was: “There wasn’t much water.”

Special cases:

  • “There was a lot of noise.” (uncountable noun)
  • “There were a lot of students.” (plural countable)

7.3. Positioning of Time Expressions

Time markers usually appear at the end or beginning:

  • “There was a concert last night.”
  • Last week, there were many meetings.”

7.4. Forming Negatives

Add not after was/were:

  • Full form: “There was not a problem.”
  • Contracted: “There wasn’t a problem.”

7.5. Forming Questions

Invert was/were and there:

  • “Was there a mistake?”
  • “Were there any calls?”

In speech, raise intonation at the end.

7.6. Using Existentials with Modal Verbs in the Past (advanced preview)

Combine modal + have been:

  • “There should have been more chairs.”
  • “There could have been a mistake.”
  • “There might have been a delay.”

7.7. Common Exceptions and Special Cases

  • Fixed phrases: “There was once…” (storytelling)
  • “There were times when…” (repeated situations)
  • Idiomatic negatives: “There was no way out.”

8. COMMON MISTAKES

8.1. Misusing ‘was’ and ‘were’ with plural/singular nouns

Incorrect: “There was many problems.”

Correct: “There were many problems.”

8.2. Omitting ‘there’ in existential sentences

Incorrect: “Was a mistake.”

Correct: “There was a mistake.”

8.3. Double subjects

Incorrect: “There it was a party.”

Correct: “There was a party.”

8.4. Overusing present tense instead of past

Incorrect: “There is a concert last night.”

Correct: “There was a concert last night.”

8.5. Negative formation errors

Incorrect: “There no was problem.”

Correct: “There was no problem.” or “There wasn’t a problem.”

8.6. Incorrect question forms

Incorrect: “There was a problem?” (informal speech)

Correct: “Was there a problem?”

8.7. Examples Table: Correct vs. Incorrect Forms

Incorrect Correct
There was many people. There were many people.
Was a mistake. There was a mistake.
There is a concert yesterday. There was a concert yesterday.
There it was a party. There was a party.
There no was problem. There was no problem.
There was a problem? Was there a problem?

9. PRACTICE EXERCISES

9.1. Fill-in-the-Blank

  1. ______ (there) many cars on the street yesterday.
  2. ______ (there) a concert last Friday.
  3. ______ (there) any milk in the fridge?
  4. ______ (there) a big storm two days ago.
  5. ______ (there) enough chairs at the meeting?
  6. ______ (there) a problem with the software?
  7. ______ (there) many complaints last month.
  8. ______ (there) much traffic this morning.
  9. ______ (there) any cookies left after the party?
  10. ______ (there) a dentist appointment yesterday.

9.2. Error Correction

  1. There was two meetings last week.
  2. There no was electricity.
  3. There were a problem with the order.
  4. Was a concert last night.
  5. There was many reasons to leave.
  6. There is a party yesterday.
  7. There were much noise.
  8. There it was a mistake.
  9. There wasn’t any people at the park.
  10. There was any tickets?

9.3. Sentence Construction

Create sentences using the prompts:

  1. a party / last Saturday
  2. many tourists / last summer
  3. any problems / yesterday
  4. plenty of food / at the celebration
  5. three emails / this morning
  6. a storm / two days ago
  7. no time / to finish the project
  8. any calls / during the meeting
  9. a concert / in 2010
  10. several complaints / last week

9.4. Transformations

  1. There is a problem. → (past)
  2. There are many books. → (past)
  3. There was a mistake. → (negative)
  4. There were some calls. → (question)
  5. There is enough food. → (past negative)
  6. There are several reasons. → (past question)
  7. There was an accident. → (question)
  8. There were many options. → (negative)
  9. There is a concert. → (past)
  10. There are any problems? → (correct question in past)

9.5. Mixed Practice

Combine fill-ins, corrections, and transformations:

  1. ______ (there) a test last Monday?
  2. There was many people at the event. (correct)
  3. There no was milk in the fridge. (correct)
  4. Change to negative: There were several errors.
  5. There is a message. (change to past question)
  6. ______ (there) any rain last night?
  7. There was a lot of noise. (change to question)
  8. There were a accident on the road. (correct)
  9. ______ (there) anything interesting at the museum?
  10. There wasn’t any problems. (correct)

9.6. Answer Keys

Fill-in-the-Blank Answers

  1. There were
  2. There was
  3. Was there
  4. There was
  5. Were there
  6. Was there
  7. There were
  8. There was
  9. Were there
  10. There was

Error Correction Answers

  1. There were two meetings last week.
  2. There was no electricity.
  3. There was a problem with the order.
  4. There was a concert last night.
  5. There were many reasons to leave.
  6. There was a party yesterday.
  7. There wasn’t much noise.
  8. There was a mistake.
  9. There weren’t any people at the park.
  10. Were there any tickets?

Sentence Construction Sample Answers

  1. There was a party last Saturday.
  2. There were many tourists last summer.
  3. Were there any problems yesterday?
  4. There was plenty of food at the celebration.
  5. There were three emails this morning.
  6. There was a storm two days ago.
  7. There was no time to finish the project.
  8. Were there any calls during the meeting?
  9. There was a concert in 2010.
  10. There were several complaints last week.

Transformations Answers

  1. There was a problem.
  2. There were many books.
  3. There wasn’t a mistake.
  4. Were there any calls?
  5. There wasn’t enough food.
  6. Were there several reasons?
  7. Was there an accident?
  8. There weren’t many options.
  9. There was a concert.
  10. Were there any problems?

Mixed Practice Answers

  1. Was there
  2. There were many people at the event.
  3. There was no milk in the fridge.
  4. There weren’t several errors.
  5. Was there a message?
  6. Was there
  7. Was there a lot of noise?
  8. There was an accident on the road.
  9. Was there
  10. There weren’t any problems.

10. ADVANCED TOPICS

10.1. Existential Sentences with Modals in the Past

Use modal verbs + have been to express past possibilities, obligations, or hypotheticals:

  • “There should have been more time.”
  • “There could have been a solution.”
  • “There might have been a mistake.”
  • “There must have been a misunderstanding.”

10.2. Past Continuous Existentials

Structures like “there was/were being” + noun are rare and usually ungrammatical.

Instead, use:

  • “There were people working.”
  • “There was noise coming from the street.”

10.3. Existentials in Past Perfect

Use there had been to indicate existence before a specific past moment:

  • “There had been a problem before we arrived.”
  • “There had been several meetings by that time.”

10.4. Passive Existential Constructions in the Past

Existential sentences can combine with passive voice:

  • “There were several reports submitted yesterday.”
  • “There were five paintings stolen last year.”

10.5. Stylistic Variations and Formality

In formal writing, overusing existential “there was/were” can seem weak.

Alternatives:

  • “Many issues arose during the process.”
  • “A large crowd attended the event.”

10.6. Contrast with “It was” Structures

Difference:

  • There was = existence: “There was a problem.”
  • It was = identity or description: “It was a difficult problem.”
  • “There was a festival.” (something existed)
  • “It was fun.” (the festival was fun)

11. FAQ SECTION

  1. What is the English equivalent of the Spanish “hay” in the past tense?
    “Hay” becomes “there was” (singular) or “there were” (plural) in English.
  2. When do I use “there was” vs. “there were”?
    Use “there was” with singular or uncountable nouns, and “there were” with plural countable nouns.
  3. How do I form negative sentences with “there was/were”?
    Add not after the verb: “There wasn’t a problem.” or “There weren’t any errors.”
  4. What is the question form of “there was” and “there were”?
    Invert the verb and “there”: “Was there a problem?”, “Were there any tickets?”
  5. Can I use “there was” with plural nouns?
    No, typically use “there were”. “There was many people” is incorrect; use “There were many people.”
  6. How do I use “there had been” and when?
    Use “there had been” to indicate prior existence before a past event, e.g., “There had been a delay before we arrived.”
  7. Are contractions like “there wasn’t” and “there weren’t” acceptable in formal writing?
    Avoid contractions in formal writing; use full forms: “There was not,” “There were not.”
  8. Can I use modal verbs with past existentials?
    Yes, e.g., “There could have been a mistake.” or “There should have been more time.”
  9. What are common mistakes to avoid with past tense existentials?
    Mixing up singular/plural forms, dropping “there,” incorrect negatives, and wrong tense usage.
  10. How do I express existence in the past continuous tense?
    English rarely uses “there was being”. Instead, use active forms: “People were working.”
  11. Should I always include a time expression with “there was/were”?
    No, but time expressions help clarify when the event occurred.
  12. Is “There was once…” only for fairy tales or can I use it in other contexts?
    Mostly storytelling, but also for recounting past times in narratives.

12. CONCLUSION

Mastering the past tense forms “there was” and “there were” is essential for accurate storytelling, descriptions, and effective communication in English. Understanding when to use singular or plural, how to form negatives and questions, and how to incorporate time expressions strengthens your grasp of English grammar.

Practice extensively with the examples and exercises provided. Pay special attention to agreement, avoid common mistakes, and explore more advanced structures as your skills grow.

Correct use of existential sentences forms a foundation for expressing past existence and sets you up for more complex grammar patterns. Keep learning, practicing, and applying these structures confidently in your communication!

Leave a Comment